Top Smudge-Proof Vegan Waterproof Eyeliners for All Skin Types

Best Smudge-Proof Vegan Waterproof Eyeliners for All Skin Types

Finding an eyeliner that stays put without smudging, suits all skin types, and aligns with vegan and clean beauty values can be challenging. Below is a curated selection of top-performing eyeliners that combine long-lasting wear, precision, and clean formulations to meet these needs.

Ultra-Fine Gel Eyeliners with Smudge-Proof Wear

Waterproof Precision Eyeliner

This ultra-fine 1.5MM gel eyeliner offers precise application with a micro-precise tip that glides effortlessly, allowing you to create sharp, defined lines without the need for a sharpener. Its long-lasting, smudge-proof formula ensures your look stays intact throughout the day. Dermatologist tested and suitable for all skin types, it features a clean formulation free from alcohol, soy, and gluten. The refillable case reduces plastic waste by 80%, supporting sustainable beauty practices. Available in four rich shades—Checkmate (Black), Lovesick (Burgundy), Memories of Blue (Navy), and Nights in Bordeaux (Plum)—this eyeliner blends performance with eco-conscious packaging.

Precision Waterproof Eyeliner Refill

For those who already own the refillable case, this refill offers the same ultra-fine 1.5MM gel formula with smudge-proof, long-lasting color. It shares the same clean, vegan, and cruelty-free credentials, making it an excellent choice for reducing waste while maintaining flawless eye definition. Available in the same four versatile shades, it suits all skin types and delivers effortless precision.

Gel and Liquid Liners for Flexible, Smudge-Resistant Looks

Clean Line Gel Liner

This gel liner features a soft tip that glides smoothly across the lids, allowing blending before it sets. Its water-resistant formula stays put once dry, giving you the flexibility to create anything from a diffused smoky eye to a bold, defined line. Suitable for all skin types—including dry, mature, sensitive, and blemish-prone skin—this vegan and fragrance-free liner comes in two shades: Twilight (deep black) and Dusk (rich brown). Its blendable texture makes it ideal for those who want control over their eyeliner intensity and finish.

Clean Line Liquid Liner

Designed for precise definition, this liquid liner has an ultra-fine felt tip that glides on easily and dries quickly to prevent creasing or feathering. Its smudge-proof formula lasts all day, making it perfect for creating everything from subtle tight lines to dramatic cat eyes. Suitable for all skin types, including sensitive and mature skin, it is free from gluten, fragrance, and soy. The single shade, Midnight Express (black), offers intense color payoff with clean ingredients that meet The Credo Clean Standard™.

Creamy Matte Kôhl Eyeliner for Intense Definition and Blendability

Eye Love You Eye Liner

This kôhl pencil combines intense matte pigment with a velvet-soft texture that glides on smoothly without skipping or dragging. Its ultra-clean formula is gentle enough for the delicate eye area, including the inner waterline. The sharpenable pencil format allows you to customize your look, from dramatic lines to soft, smoky blends. Suitable for all skin types, it contains nourishing ingredients like jojoba and shea butter to support comfort during wear. Available in Khôl Noir (black) and Khôl Brun (brown), this cruelty-free and fragrance-free liner is a versatile choice for those seeking a rich, blendable finish.

Summary of Features Across These Vegan Waterproof Eyeliners

ProductFormula TypeSmudge-ProofWaterproof/Water-ResistantSuitable for All Skin TypesVegan & CleanPackaging HighlightsPrice Range (USD)
Waterproof Precision EyelinerUltra-fine gelYesYesYesYesRefillable, 80% less plastic$23
Precision Waterproof RefillUltra-fine gelYesYesYesYesRefill for eco-conscious use$17
Clean Line Gel LinerGelYesWater-resistantYesYes-$26
Clean Line Liquid LinerLiquid (felt tip)YesYesYesYes-$28
Eye Love You Eye LinerKôhl pencilYesNot specifiedYesYesSharpenable pencil$34

Choosing the Right Vegan Waterproof Eyeliner for You

  • For ultra-precise, long-lasting lines with eco-friendly packaging: The Waterproof Precision Eyeliner and its refill offer a clean, smudge-proof gel formula with a fine tip and sustainable design.
  • For blendable, water-resistant gel application: The Clean Line Gel Liner provides smooth glide and flexible looks, ideal for those who want to blend before setting.
  • For sharp, quick-dry liquid definition: The Clean Line Liquid Liner’s felt tip ensures precise control and all-day wear without smudging.
  • For creamy, intense matte kôhl: Eye Love You Eye Liner delivers rich pigment with a soft texture that can be sharpened for customized looks.
Each of these eyeliners is formulated to be vegan, cruelty-free, and suitable for all skin types, including sensitive and mature skin, ensuring you can find a product that fits your style and values.
Elevate your eye makeup with these clean, smudge-proof, and waterproof vegan eyeliners designed for effortless precision and lasting wear. Whether you prefer gel, liquid, or pencil, these options provide reliable performance with skin-friendly ingredients and sustainable packaging choices.
FeatureWaterproof Precision EyelinerPrecision Waterproof Eyeliner RefillClean Line Gel LinerClean Line Liquid LinerEye Love You Eye Liner
BrandSOSHE BeautySOSHE BeautyILIA BeautyILIA BeautyWestman Atelier
TypeGel EyelinerGel Eyeliner RefillGel EyelinerLiquid EyelinerKôhl Pencil Eyeliner
Tip SizeUltra-fine 1.5MMUltra-fine 1.5MMSoft tip gel linerUltra-fine felt tipPencil (sharpenable)
ApplicationPrecise, no sharpener requiredPrecise, no sharpener requiredGlides on smoothly, blendableUltra-fine tip, quick-dryGlide on intense matte pigment, smudge/blendable
FinishSmudge-proof, long-lastingSmudge-proof, long-lastingWater-resistant, sets after blendingSmudge-proof, all-day wearMatte
Colors AvailableCheckmate (Black), Lovesick (Burgundy), Memories of Blue (Navy), Nights in Bordeaux (Plum)Same as main linerTwilight (Black), Dusk (Brown)Midnight Express (Black)Khôl Noir (Black), Khôl Brun (Brown)
Price$23.00$17.00$26.00$28.00$34.00
Suitable ForAll skin typesAll skin typesAll skin types including dry, mature, sensitive, combination, normalAll skin types including dry, mature, sensitive, combination, normalAll skin types
Key FeaturesClean formulation, refillable packaging, dermatologist tested, cruelty free, vegan, gluten free, alcohol free, soy free, sustainable packagingSame as main linerClean, fragrance free, vegan, gluten free, soy free, water-resistantClean, fragrance free, vegan, gluten free, soy freeUltra-clean ingredients, cruelty free, fragrance free, paraben free
PackagingRefillable case, 80% less plasticRefill for refillable caseStandard packagingStandard packagingSharpenable pencil format
Clean StandardMeets The Credo Clean Standard™Meets The Credo Clean Standard™Meets The Credo Clean Standard™Meets The Credo Clean Standard™Ultra-clean formula
Reviews Rating4.4 stars (288 reviews)4.8 stars (62 reviews)4.4 stars (235 reviews)4.4 stars (382 reviews)4.4 stars (39 reviews)
What are the best smudge-proof vegan waterproof eyeliners for all skin types?The best smudge-proof vegan waterproof eyeliners for all skin types include the Waterproof Precision Eyeliner, Precision Waterproof Eyeliner Refill, Clean Line Gel Liner, Clean Line Liquid Liner, and Eye Love You Eye Liner. These products offer long-lasting wear, clean formulations, and are suitable for sensitive, mature, dry, and blemish-prone skin.
Are these eyeliners suitable for sensitive or mature skin?Yes, all the featured eyeliners are dermatologist tested and formulated to be gentle on sensitive and mature skin. They are free from common irritants like fragrance, gluten, soy, and alcohol, making them safe for all skin types.
Which vegan eyeliner is best for precise application and eco-friendly packaging?The Waterproof Precision Eyeliner and its refill are ideal for precise application thanks to their ultra-fine 1.5MM gel tip. They also feature a refillable case that reduces plastic waste by 80%, making them an eco-friendly choice.
What shades are available for these vegan waterproof eyeliners?The Waterproof Precision Eyeliner and its refill come in Checkmate (Black), Lovesick (Burgundy), Memories of Blue (Navy), and Nights in Bordeaux (Plum). The Clean Line Gel Liner is available in Twilight (deep black) and Dusk (rich brown). The Clean Line Liquid Liner is offered in Midnight Express (black), and the Eye Love You Eye Liner comes in Khôl Noir (black) and Khôl Brun (brown).
Are these eyeliners cruelty-free and vegan?Yes, all the eyeliners listed are 100% vegan and cruelty-free. They are formulated without animal-derived ingredients and are not tested on animals.
Which eyeliner is best for creating a smoky or blended look?The Clean Line Gel Liner and Eye Love You Eye Liner are best for creating smoky or blended looks. Both have soft, blendable textures that allow you to smudge and diffuse the line before it sets.
Do any of these eyeliners have a refillable or sustainable packaging option?Yes, the Waterproof Precision Eyeliner features a refillable case that reduces plastic waste by 80%. The Precision Waterproof Eyeliner Refill is available for those who already own the case, supporting sustainable beauty practices.
Are these eyeliners free from common allergens like gluten, soy, and fragrance?Yes, these eyeliners are formulated without gluten, soy, and fragrance, making them suitable for individuals with allergies or sensitivities.
What is the price range for these vegan waterproof eyeliners?The price range for these vegan waterproof eyeliners is between $17 and $34 USD, depending on the product and whether you are purchasing a refill or a full-size liner.
Which eyeliner is best for the waterline or inner eye area?The Eye Love You Eye Liner is specifically formulated to be gentle enough for the delicate eye area, including the inner waterline, thanks to its ultra-clean formula and nourishing ingredients like jojoba and shea butter.
What are the key benefits of using the Waterproof Precision Eyeliner?Can you tell me more about the Clean Line Gel Liner and its features?What is your return policy for the eyeliners?
Find your favorites, powered by Big Sur AI