Dermatologist Tested Waterproof Gel Eyeliner Refills for Sensitive Eyes

Dermatologist Tested Waterproof Gel Eyeliner Refill for Sensitive Eyes and Skin

When it comes to choosing a gel eyeliner that is gentle on sensitive eyes and skin, while offering long-lasting, waterproof performance, several dermatologist-tested options stand out. Below, we explore top clean beauty gel eyeliners and refills designed for precise application, smudge resistance, and skin-friendly formulations.

SOSHE Beauty Precision Waterproof Eyeliner Refill

Ultra-Fine, Long-Lasting Gel Formula

The SOSHE Precision Waterproof Eyeliner Refill features an ultra-fine 1.5MM gel tip that delivers rich, smudge-proof color designed for precise application without the need for sharpening. This refill is ideal for those who want to maintain a clean, sustainable beauty routine with a refillable case that reduces plastic waste by 80%.

Skin-Friendly and Clean

Formulated without alcohol, gluten, or soy, this vegan and cruelty-free eyeliner meets The Credo Clean Standard™. It has been dermatologist tested, making it suitable for all skin types, including sensitive eyes. The clean ingredients ensure a gentle yet effective wear.

Shade Range

Available in versatile shades such as Checkmate (True Black), Lovesick (Burgundy Brown), and Nights in Bordeaux (Plum), this refill allows you to customize your look from classic to bold.
Designed for effortless precision, this refill supports sharp cat-eyes, tight lines, or bold wings with a micro-precise tip.

SOSHE Beauty Waterproof Precision Eyeliner

Ready-to-Use Gel Eyeliner with Refillable Packaging

This full-size gel eyeliner shares the same ultra-fine 1.5MM tip and clean, smudge-proof formula as the refill. It is dermatologist tested and crafted for all skin types, including sensitive skin. The refillable case uses 80% less plastic, aligning with sustainable beauty values.

Features and Benefits

  • Vegan, gluten-free, alcohol-free, and soy-free
  • Long-lasting, smudge-proof color
  • Micro-precise tip for effortless control
  • Available in four shades: Checkmate (Black), Memories of Blue (Navy), Lovesick (Burgundy), and Nights in Bordeaux (Plum)
This eyeliner offers a clean, precise application experience with a formula gentle enough for sensitive eyes.

ILIA Clean Line Gel Liner

Soft Tip Gel for Smooth Application and Blendability

ILIA’s Clean Line Gel Liner glides on smoothly with a soft tip that allows blending before setting, giving you the flexibility to create anything from a diffused smoky eye to a sharp, defined line. Once dry, it stays put and is water resistant.

Suitable for Sensitive Skin

This gel liner is fragrance-free, vegan, gluten-free, and soy-free, making it a great choice for sensitive, dry, mature, or blemish-prone skin. It is designed to be gentle yet effective for all skin types.

Shade Options

Available in Twilight (deepest black) and Dusk (rich brown), it covers essential classic shades for everyday wear.
A versatile gel liner that balances ease of use with a water-resistant finish, suitable for sensitive eyes.

Kosas Soulgazer Intensifying Gel Eyeliner

Waterproof Gel with Hyaluronic Acid

Kosas Soulgazer is a retractable gel eyeliner powered by hyaluronic acid, which helps the pencil glide smoothly and apply evenly. This clean formula is waterproof and offers rich color payoff in both matte and satin finishes.

Skin-Soothing and Clean

Formulated without alcohol, fragrance, gluten, or soy, and cruelty-free and vegan, this eyeliner is suitable for all skin types, including sensitive eyes. The built-in sharpener and smudger make it easy to customize your look.

Color Variety

Choose from a broad palette including Hypnotize (intense black matte), Orbit (smokey gray matte), Allure (dark brown matte), and several satin shades like Enigma (blackened blue satin) and Eternal (emerald green satin).
Combines smooth application with skin-hydrating benefits, ideal for sensitive skin needing waterproof wear.

Summary: Choosing the Best Dermatologist Tested Waterproof Gel Eyeliner for Sensitive Eyes

  • For refillable, ultra-precise gel liners: SOSHE Beauty’s Precision Waterproof Eyeliner Refill offers a clean, sustainable option with dermatologist-tested safety and a fine 1.5MM tip for detailed looks.
  • For a ready-to-use, refillable gel liner: SOSHE Beauty’s Waterproof Precision Eyeliner provides the same clean formula and precision in a full-size product.
  • For blendable, water-resistant gel liner: ILIA Clean Line Gel Liner suits sensitive skin with its fragrance-free, vegan formula and soft tip for easy blending.
  • For a hydrating, retractable gel liner: Kosas Soulgazer intensifies eyes with hyaluronic acid, delivering smooth, waterproof color in a variety of shades and finishes.
Each of these options prioritizes gentle, dermatologist-tested formulations that respect sensitive eyes and skin while delivering long-lasting, waterproof performance.
All products mentioned are cruelty-free, vegan, and formulated without harsh ingredients like alcohol, gluten, and soy, making them suitable choices for sensitive skin and eyes.
FeaturePrecision Waterproof Eyeliner RefillWaterproof Precision EyelinerClean Line Gel LinerSoulgazer Intensifying Gel Eyeliner
BrandSOSHE BeautySOSHE BeautyILIA BeautyKosas
TypeGel Eyeliner RefillGel EyelinerGel EyelinerRetractable Gel Eyeliner
Price$17.00$23.00$26.00$24.00
Color VariantsCheckmate (Black), Lovesick (Burgundy), Memories of Blue (Navy), Nights in Bordeaux (plum)Checkmate (Black), Lovesick (Burgundy), Memories of Blue (Navy), Nights in Bordeaux (plum)Twilight (Black), Dusk (Brown)10 shades including Hypnotize (Black Matte), Enigma (Blackened Blue Satin), etc.
Application TipUltra-fine 1.5MM gel, no sharpener requiredUltra-fine 1.5MM gel, no sharpener requiredSoft tip gel, glides and blends easilyRetractable pencil with built-in sharpener
FinishSmudge-proof, long-lastingSmudge-proof, long-lastingWater-resistant, sets after blendingMatte and Satin finishes
Suitable ForAll skin typesAll skin typesAll skin types including dry, mature, sensitive, blemish-prone, combination, normalAll skin types
Key FeaturesClean formulation, smudge-proof, refillable packaging, dermatologist tested, vegan, gluten free, alcohol free, soy free, cruelty free, sustainable packagingClean formulation, smudge-proof, refillable packaging, dermatologist tested, vegan, gluten free, alcohol free, soy free, cruelty free, sustainable packagingClean, water-resistant, vegan, gluten free, fragrance free, soy free, cruelty freeClean, waterproof, powered by Hyaluronic Acid, creamy gel, retractable, smudger included, vegan, gluten free, fragrance free, alcohol free, cruelty free
PackagingRefillable case using 80% less plasticRefillable case using 80% less plasticStandard packagingRetractable pencil packaging
Dermatologist TestedYesYesNot specifiedNot specified
Clean StandardThe Credo Clean Standard™The Credo Clean Standard™Not specifiedNot specified
Reviews Rating4.8 stars (62 reviews)4.4 stars (288 reviews)4.4 stars (235 reviews)4.4 stars (53 reviews)
What is the best dermatologist-tested waterproof gel eyeliner for sensitive eyes?Top dermatologist-tested waterproof gel eyeliners for sensitive eyes include SOSHE Beauty Precision Waterproof Eyeliner Refill, SOSHE Beauty Waterproof Precision Eyeliner, ILIA Clean Line Gel Liner, and Kosas Soulgazer Intensifying Gel Eyeliner. All are formulated to be gentle on sensitive eyes and skin, offering long-lasting, smudge-proof, and waterproof performance.
Are there refillable waterproof gel eyeliners suitable for sensitive skin?Yes, SOSHE Beauty offers both a Precision Waterproof Eyeliner Refill and a Waterproof Precision Eyeliner with refillable packaging. These products are dermatologist tested, vegan, cruelty-free, and formulated without alcohol, gluten, or soy, making them ideal for sensitive skin and eyes.
What ingredients are avoided in these gel eyeliners for sensitive eyes?All featured gel eyeliners are formulated without harsh ingredients such as alcohol, gluten, soy, and fragrance. They are also vegan and cruelty-free, ensuring they are gentle and safe for sensitive eyes and skin.
Which gel eyeliner is best for creating precise lines and cat eyes?The SOSHE Beauty Precision Waterproof Eyeliner Refill and Waterproof Precision Eyeliner both feature an ultra-fine 1.5MM gel tip, perfect for creating sharp cat-eyes, tight lines, and bold wings with micro-precise control.
Are there waterproof gel eyeliners that are easy to blend for a smoky eye look?ILIA Clean Line Gel Liner is designed with a soft tip that glides on smoothly and allows for easy blending before setting. This makes it ideal for creating both diffused smoky eyes and sharp, defined lines.
Do any waterproof gel eyeliners offer hydrating benefits for sensitive skin?Kosas Soulgazer Intensifying Gel Eyeliner is formulated with hyaluronic acid, which helps hydrate the skin while providing smooth, waterproof color. It is suitable for sensitive skin and eyes.
What shade options are available for these dermatologist-tested gel eyeliners?SOSHE Beauty eyeliners are available in shades like Checkmate (Black), Lovesick (Burgundy), Nights in Bordeaux (Plum), and Memories of Blue (Navy). ILIA Clean Line Gel Liner comes in Twilight (Black) and Dusk (Brown). Kosas Soulgazer offers a wide range including Hypnotize (Black Matte), Orbit (Gray Matte), Allure (Brown Matte), Enigma (Blackened Blue Satin), and Eternal (Emerald Green Satin).
Are these waterproof gel eyeliners cruelty-free and vegan?Yes, all the gel eyeliners mentioned—SOSHE Beauty, ILIA, and Kosas—are cruelty-free and vegan, making them ethical choices for beauty routines.
How do refillable gel eyeliners help with sustainability?Refillable gel eyeliners like those from SOSHE Beauty use up to 80% less plastic compared to traditional eyeliners, supporting a more sustainable and eco-friendly beauty routine.
Are these gel eyeliners suitable for all skin types, including mature or blemish-prone skin?Yes, these dermatologist-tested gel eyeliners are formulated to be gentle and effective for all skin types, including sensitive, dry, mature, and blemish-prone skin.
Can you tell me more about the shade options available for the SOSHE Beauty Precision Waterproof Eyeliner Refill?Is the ILIA Clean Line Gel Liner suitable for all skin types, including sensitive skin?What is your return policy for makeup products if I am not satisfied with my purchase?
Find your favorites, powered by Big Sur AI