Brand | Doctor Rogers | Grown Alchemist | Ursa Major | Indie Lee |
Texture/Formulation | Gel cleanser | Gel cleanser | Foaming gel cleanser | Gel cleanser |
Key Benefits | Removes makeup, sunscreen, daily buildup in one wash; gentle, non-stripping | Brightens, balances, decongests; soothes and calms; reduces appearance of pores | Thorough, invigorating cleanse; AHA/BHA exfoliation; maintains pH balance | Antioxidant-rich; removes makeup (incl. eye); doubles as exfoliating mask; brightens |
Suitable For | All skin types, including sensitive | All skin types, especially combination | Normal, combination, oily skin | All skin types |
Notable Ingredients | Coco-glucoside, aloe vera, glycerin | Aloe vera, chamomile, bergamot, willow bark | Aloe vera, sugarcane, lemon, orange, maple | Strawberry seed oil, wheat protein, tomato extracts, lycopene |
Vegan/Gluten Free/Soy Free | Vegan, gluten free, soy free | Vegan, gluten free, soy free | Gluten free | Not specified (formulated without essential oils, fragrance, parabens) |
Fragrance | Not specified | Botanical (geranium, orange, bergamot, rose) | Cedar, lime, spearmint | Uplifting, light fruity, strawberry scent |
Makeup Removal | Yes | Not specified | Not specified | Yes (including eye makeup) |
Exfoliation | No | Mild (willow bark) | Yes (AHA/BHA) | Yes (gentle, with lycopene and as mask) |
Size Options | 5 oz / 150 ml | 6.76 oz / 200 ml | 2 oz / 60 ml, 4 oz / 120 ml, 8 oz / 235 ml | 1 oz / 30 ml, 4 oz / 120 ml, 10 oz / 300 ml |
Price (for standard size) | $38 (5 oz) | $38 (6.76 oz) | $15 (2 oz), $26 (4 oz), $32 (8 oz) | $11 (1 oz), $38 (4 oz) |
Cruelty Free | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Rating (Reviews) | 4.9 (231 reviews) | 4.6 (334 reviews) | 4.7 (337 reviews) | 4.8 (738 reviews) |