Best Matte Cream Eyeshadows with Sustainable Recycled Packaging

Looking for a matte cream eyeshadow that not only delivers stunning color and performance but also comes in sustainable, recycled packaging? Discover our top picks for eco-conscious beauty lovers. Each product below is vegan, cruelty-free, and thoughtfully designed to minimize environmental impact—without compromising on style or wear.

---

1. RMS Beauty Cashmere Matte Eyelights

Cashmere-Soft, Creaseproof Cream Eyeshadow in 100% Recycled Aluminum Tubes

Experience the next generation of matte eyeshadow with RMS Beauty’s Cashmere Matte Eyelights. This innovative cream formula offers a cashmere-soft, matte pearl finish in eight nourishing, fashion-forward shades. The long-wearing, creaseproof texture is perfect for all-day wear, and the subtle brilliance ensures your eyes look radiant yet sophisticated. Key Features:

• Matte cream formula with a soft, pearl finish
• Long-wearing & creaseproof for all-day confidence
• Nourishing ingredients: Organic Green Tea Extract (antioxidant) and Natural Peptide Quinoa Extract (smooths and firms eyelids)

Vegan, cruelty-free, gluten-free, fragrance-free, paraben-free

• Sustainable packaging: Artist’s tube made from 100% recycled aluminum—squeeze out every last drop and recycle with ease

Available Shades: Canyon Clay (rustic brown-red), Mountain Mist (cloudy silver-gray), Tundra Taupe (light desert sand), Dusty Trail (tawny camel brown), Desert Rose (soft vintage pink), Mallo Coast (dusty rose-mauve), Wildflower (delicate pale lavender), and more.

“Matte eyeshadows can look dry and hard, so I wanted to give these a slight matte pearl finish that has a gorgeous subtle brilliance to it while feeling soft like cashmere.”
— Rose-Marie Swift, RMS Beauty Founder

---

2. ILIA Beauty Liquid Powder Eye Tint

Cream-to-Powder Matte Eyeshadow with Quick-Dry, Vegan Formula

ILIA’s Liquid Powder Eye Tint is a modern take on cream eyeshadow, offering a lightweight, water-based formula that glides on as a cream and dries down to a crease-resistant, powdery matte finish. Perfect for those who want effortless application and a clean, vegan formula. Key Features:

• Cream-to-powder formula for easy blending and a soft matte look

Quick-dry, water-based, and crease-resistant Vegan and suitable for all skin types

• Key ingredient: Horse chestnut flower for skin nourishment
• Sustainable packaging: ILIA is committed to eco-friendly practices, with packaging designed for minimal waste and recyclability

Available Matte Shades: Fresco (taupe brown), Tannin (rich brown), Cork (taupe brown), Dove (dove gray), and more.

---

---

3. MOB Beauty Cream Clay Matte Eyeshadow

Refillable, Recycled, and Biodegradable Matte Cream Eyeshadow

MOB Beauty’s Cream Clay Matte Eyeshadow is a standout for sustainability and performance. This cream eyeshadow is infused with clay for a semi-powder dry down, delivering rich pigment that can be sheered out for a soft wash or built up for bold color. The compact is made from 90% post-consumer recycled fiber and is fully biodegradable, while the eyeshadow pan is crafted from 100% post-consumer recycled PET. Key Features:

• Cream formula with semi-powder finish for versatile looks
• Infused with clay for smooth blending and long wear

Vegan, cruelty-free, gluten-free, fragrance-free, alcohol-free, soy-free

• Sustainable packaging: 90% post-consumer recycled fiber compact, 100% recycled PET pan, refillable and biodegradable
• Customizable palettes: Easily pop out pans to create your own palette

Available Shades: M81 (cyan blue), M83 (lavender), M85 (mint seafoam green), M88 (softest dusty pink), M105 (burnt sienna), M107 (muted wheat), M112 (greige stone), M113 (golden camel), M114 (muted rose), M115 (taupe), and more.

---

---

Why Choose Matte Cream Eyeshadow with Sustainable Packaging?

Choosing eyeshadows with recycled and recyclable packaging helps reduce beauty industry waste and supports a cleaner planet. These products not only deliver high-performance, creaseproof color but also align with your values for sustainability and conscious consumption.

“Help us end beauty packaging waste. Disassemble and clean all components, pick the right disposal bin, and drop off your empties at your nearest Pact bin.”

---

Summary Table

---

---

Make Your Beauty Routine Greener

With these matte cream eyeshadows, you can enjoy beautiful, long-lasting color while making a positive impact on the environment. Choose your favorite shades and feel good about every application—beauty that’s as good for the planet as it is for your eyes.