Type | Makeup, Eye, Eyeliner Refill | Makeup, Eye, Eyeliner | Makeup, Eye, Eyeliner | Makeup, Eye, Eyeliner | Skin Care, Eye Care, Eye Cream Refill |
Price | $17.00 | $20.00 | $23.00 | $26.00 | $69.00 |
Color Variants | Checkmate (Black), Lovesick (Burgundy), Memories of Blue (Navy), Nights in Bordeaux (plum) | M41 (Black), M89 (Midnight Blue), M90 (Deep Brown) | Checkmate (Black), Lovesick (Burgundy), Memories of Blue (Navy), Nights in Bordeaux (plum) | Twilight (Black), Dusk (Brown) | N/A |
Formulation | Ultra-fine 1.5MM gel eyeliner, smudge-proof, long-lasting | Dense, inky, talc-free cake powder liner, smudge-proof, transfer resistant | Ultra-fine 1.5MM gel eyeliner, smudge-proof, long-lasting | Soft tip gel eyeliner, water-resistant, blendable | Eye treatment cream that brightens, firms, reduces fine lines |
Suitable For | All skin types | All skin types and ages | All skin types | All skin types including dry, mature, sensitive, blemish-prone, combination, normal | All skin types |
Key Features | No sharpener required, refillable, clean formulation, dermatologist tested, cruelty free, vegan, gluten free, alcohol free, soy free, sustainable packaging | Clean & vegan, talc-free, hypoallergenic, biodegradable packaging, refillable, recyclable | No sharpener required, refillable case with 80% less plastic, vegan, gluten free, alcohol free, soy free, sustainable packaging | Easy to apply, blendable, water-resistant, vegan, gluten free, fragrance free, soy free | Brightens, firms, improves fine lines, cruelty free, vegan, fragrance free, paraben free, sustainable packaging |
Packaging | Refillable component, uses 80% less plastic per refill | Compact with 90% post-consumer recycled fiber, pan made with 100% post-consumer recycled PET, biodegradable | Refillable case with 80% less plastic per refill | Standard packaging (not specified as refillable) | Refillable packaging |
Application | Micro-precise tip for effortless, precise application | Use wet for various looks from precise to dramatic | Micro-precise tip for effortless, precise application | Glide on and blend before setting for flexible looks | Dab small amount on eye contour morning and evening |
Ingredients Highlights | Trimethylsiloxysilicate, methyl trimethicone, candelilla wax, synthetic wax | Mica, rice bran wax, biodegradable corn starch polymers | Similar to refill, clean formulation | Dimethicone, polymethylsilsesquioxane, polyisobutene, iron oxides | Human Tripeptide-1, Ribose, microencapsulated CoQ10, Hyaluronic Acid |
Reviews Rating | 4.8 stars (62 reviews) | 4.8 stars (86 reviews) | 4.4 stars (288 reviews) | 4.4 stars (235 reviews) | Not rated (no reviews provided) |
Brand / Founder Info | SOSHE Beauty, AAPI-Founded, Women Founded | MOB Beauty, Women Founded | SOSHE Beauty, AAPI-Founded, Women Founded | ILIA Beauty, Women Founded | Emma Lewisham, Vegan Skin Care |
Additional Notes | Meets The Credo Clean Standard™, cruelty free, vegan, gluten free, alcohol free, soy free | Co-founded nonprofit Pact for recycling, sustainable packaging | Meets The Credo Clean Standard™, cruelty free, vegan, gluten free, alcohol free, soy free | Fragrance free, vegan, gluten free, soy free | Fragrance free, paraben free, vegan, cruelty free |