The Best Clean Ingredient Eyebrow Pencils for Beginners with Neutral Undertones

Looking for the perfect eyebrow pencil that’s beginner-friendly, made with clean ingredients, and suits neutral undertones? Discover our curated selection of top-rated brow pencils that deliver natural, effortless results—ideal for those just starting their brow journey or anyone seeking a fuss-free, clean beauty routine.

---

Why Choose Clean Ingredient Brow Pencils?

Clean beauty means products formulated without potentially harmful ingredients, focusing on skin health and environmental responsibility. For beginners, clean brow pencils offer gentle, nourishing formulas that are easy to use and deliver natural-looking results.

---

Top Eyebrow Pencils for Beginners with Neutral Undertones

1. ILIA In Full Micro-Tip Brow Pencil

Perfect for Beginners & Neutral Undertones

• Ultra-Slim Micro-Tip: Effortlessly creates thin, hairlike strokes for a natural look.
• Beginner-Friendly: 100% of users in a clinical study said it was easy to use and perfect for beginners.
• Buildable, Soft Pigment: Allows for mistake-proof application and easy blending.

Shades for Neutral Undertones:

• Dark Blonde: For light to medium blonde hair with neutral undertones
• Taupe: For medium blonde to light brown hair with neutral cool undertones
• Soft Brown: For medium brown hair with neutral undertones
• Dark Brown: For medium to deep brown hair with neutral undertones
• Key Ingredients: Mineral-based pigments, Provitamin B5 for brow nourishment.
• Sustainable Packaging: Good for you and the planet.

“The foolproof formula takes the guesswork out of defining your best brows—each swipe deposits the perfect amount of pigment that resists fading and budging throughout the day.”

---

2. Kosas Brow Pop Dual-Action Defining Pencil

Dual-Action Precision for Effortless Brows

• Micro Triangle Tip: Thicker side fills in sparseness, thinner point shapes and defines.
• Clean, Vegan Formula: Free of drying alcohols, fragrance, silicone, mineral oil, synthetic waxes, and microplastics.
• Nourishing Ingredients: Castor oil and panthenol pro vitamin B5 support brow health.

Shades for Neutral Undertones:

• Medium Brown: Neutral medium brown
• Soft Brown: Light brown/dark blonde (suits neutral undertones)
• Taupe: Cool blonde (for those with neutral-cool undertones)
• Built-In Spoolie: For blending and a natural finish.
• Clinical Results: 100% agreed brows had a natural look; 97% found it easy to shape their brows.

---

3. Westman Atelier Bonne Brow Defining Pencil

Natural Definition Meets Feathery Fullness

• Dual-Ended Tool: Retractable pencil for filling and defining, detachable spoolie for grooming.
• 100% Naturally-Derived Pigments: Clean, buildable formula with just-the-right glide.
• Firm-Yet-Gentle Texture: Glides on evenly for hair-like strokes.

Shades for Neutral Undertones:

• Clay: Taupe blonde, ideal for medium blonde and brown hair (neutral undertones)
• Bark: Woodsy brown, for dark brown hair (neutral to cool undertones)
• Vegan, Fragrance-Free, Paraben-Free: Suitable for all skin types.

---

4. RÓEN BEAUTY VowBROW Pencil

Micro-Tip Precision for Natural-Looking Brows

• 1.7mm Micro Tip: Designed for precise, hair-like strokes.
• Firm Formula: Allows for controlled, natural application.
• Clean, Vegan, Gluten-Free: Meets high clean beauty standards.

Shades for Neutral Undertones:

• Light (Taupe): For blonde, grey, or light brown hair
• Medium (Brown): For light brown, brown, or black hair
• Easy to Shape, Fill, and Define: Perfect for beginners seeking a natural look.

---

5. RMS Beauty Back2Brow Pencil

Classic Wooden Pencil for Seamless Blending

• Longwear Formula: Stays put all day, blends seamlessly for natural brows.

Three Natural-Looking Shades:

• Light (Soft, Beige Taupe): Ideal for blonde/light brown hair
• Medium (Muted, Medium Warm Brown): Ideal for brown/auburn hair
• Dark (Deep Espresso): For dark brown/black hair
• Clean Ingredients: Includes jojoba oil, sunflower seed oil, and rosemary extract.
• Pro Tip: Sharpen before use for the best application.

---

How to Choose the Right Shade for Neutral Undertones

For neutral undertones, look for shades labeled as “taupe,” “soft brown,” or “medium brown.” These shades avoid overly warm or cool tones, blending seamlessly with your natural brow color for a balanced, flattering look.

---

Tips for Beginners

• Start Light: Use gentle, short strokes to mimic natural brow hairs.
• Blend Well: Use the spoolie to soften lines and blend color.
• Build Gradually: Layer color for desired fullness without overdoing it.
• Choose Clean: Opt for pencils with nourishing, non-irritating ingredients—especially important for sensitive skin.

---

Clean Beauty, Confidence, and Effortless Brows

Whether you’re just starting out or looking to simplify your routine, these clean ingredient eyebrow pencils are designed to make brow shaping easy, safe, and beautiful—especially for those with neutral undertones. Enjoy natural definition, healthy ingredients, and confidence in every stroke.

---

Note: All products featured are cruelty-free, and most are vegan and fragrance-free, making them suitable for sensitive skin and conscious beauty lovers.

---

Images: *No lifestyle images available for this selection. For best results, pair your brow routine with natural lighting and a gentle hand for the most flattering, beginner-friendly look.*