The Best Clean Buildable Mascaras with Shea Butter-Like Nourishment for Lifted, Lengthened, and Healthy Lashes

Looking for a clean, buildable mascara that not only lifts and lengthens but also nourishes your lashes—just like shea butter? Discover our curated selection of high-performance mascaras, each formulated with lash-loving ingredients to deliver dramatic results while caring for sensitive eyes and delicate lashes. Whether you want a natural look or bold, amplified volume, these mascaras are designed to be layered for your perfect finish.

---

1. Ere Perez Avocado Waterproof Mascara

Nourishing, Volumizing, and Waterproof

Experience the power of nature with Ere Perez Avocado Waterproof Mascara. This clean, vegan formula is infused with mamey and avocado oils, which are known to stimulate lash growth and promote strength—offering nourishment similar to shea butter. Perfect for all skin types, including sensitive eyes, this mascara delivers: Waterproof, smudge-proof, and 24-hour wear Volumizing and buildable coverage Full black or brown shades Made with high-quality natural ingredients Cruelty-free, vegan, gluten-free, and fragrance-free

"This mascara is a favorite for those seeking a barely-there look with a matte or dewy finish, while still enjoying the benefits of natural oils for lash health."

---

2. Plume Science Nourish & Amplify Mascara

Growth-Activated, Buildable Drama

Plume Science’s Nourish & Amplify Mascara is a clean, high-performance option for those who want instant drama and long-term lash health. Its patented actives and moisturizing ingredients work together to promote longer, fuller, and thicker lashes over time. Highly buildable formula for length and volume Long-wearing, non-flaking, intense black pigment Free from micro-plastics, silicones, and other harsh chemicals Moisturizing with hydrolyzed jojoba esters and baobab seed extract Safe for sensitive eyes and skin

"Apply one coat for length, two for volume, or three for dramatic lashes—this mascara adapts to your desired look while nourishing your lashes."

---

3. Rituel de Fille Levitation Lash Lifting + Lengthening Mascara

All-in-One Lifting, Lengthening, and Nourishing

Rituel de Fille’s Levitation Lash Mascara is a clean, vegan formula that magically lifts, lengthens, defines, curls, volumizes, and nourishes—all in one. With 95% natural ingredients, including vitamin E-rich argan and castor oils, it softens and cares for your lashes while providing: Lightweight, flake-resistant, and buildable coverage Innovative bio-based fiber brush for precision Vegan, gluten-free, fragrance-free, and alcohol-free Ophthalmologist tested and safe for sensitive eyes

"Apply one coat for a subtle look or layer for intense, clump-free drama. The nourishing oils mimic the conditioning benefits of shea butter for healthy, beautiful lashes."

---

4. Sweed Beauty Lash Lift Mascara

Award-Winning Lift, Length, and Separation

Sweed Beauty’s Lash Lift Mascara is a cult-favorite for its ability to lift, lengthen, and separate lashes with precision. Its groundbreaking skinny brush coats each lash from root to tip, creating maximum definition and volume. Lightweight, flexible, and endlessly buildable formula Glossy finish that holds a curl all day Infused with vitamin B5 for nourishment Water-resistant, flake-free, and easy to wash off Vegan, cruelty-free, and fragrance-free

"Perfect for sensitive skin, this mascara leaves lashes glossy, defined, and nourished—without clumping or smudging."

---

5. Exa ten18 Lash Amplifying Mascara

Clump-Free, Volumizing, and Buildable

Exa’s ten18 Lash Amplifying Mascara is a clean, vegan formula that delivers dramatic volume and length without clumping. Its hourglass-shaped brush separates and lifts even the tiniest lashes, while vitamin-rich orange peel fibers and rice bran wax-derived film formers amplify volume and hold curl. Buildable, flake-free, and smudge-proof Natural jet-black bamboo charcoal powder for intense color Suitable for all skin types and ages Sustainably packaged

"Whether you want wispy lashes or bold drama, this mascara lets you layer for your perfect look while nourishing your lashes."

---

6. Iris&Romeo Lash Up Peptide Thickening Mascara

Serum-Infused for Lift, Length, and Definition

Iris&Romeo’s Lash Up Peptide Thickening Mascara is powered by a pentapeptide lash serum to help thicken lashes over time. Its clean, vegan formula lifts, lengthens, and defines with all-day stay. Serum-infused for long-term lash health Vitamin B5 and patented emulsion wax blend for nourishment 100% recyclable glass bottle and sustainable brush Cruelty-free, fragrance-free, and paraben-free

"Use the unique brush to build volume and lift from root to tip, enjoying the benefits of a nourishing serum in every swipe."

---

Why Choose Clean, Buildable Mascaras with Nourishing Ingredients?

Clean mascaras formulated with natural oils, peptides, and vitamins offer more than just beautiful lashes—they help condition, strengthen, and protect, much like shea butter. These formulas are ideal for sensitive eyes and anyone seeking a healthier approach to makeup.

---

How to Get the Most Out of Your Mascara

Start with clean, dry lashes. Apply in upward strokes from root to tip. Layer for desired volume and length. Remove gently with a nourishing oil or warm water.

"With these clean, buildable mascaras, you can achieve lifted, lengthened, and nourished lashes—naturally."

---

Note: While none of these mascaras list shea butter specifically, they are formulated with similar nourishing oils and conditioning agents to deliver the same benefits for your lashes.